From
October 28, 2009
A Stern message to the world
Responding to climate change is an urgent necessity but a viable solution lies in adequate mitigation and new industrial practices rather than our eating habits
Now Lord Stern of Brentford, the economist and author of the Stern report on climate change, espouses a more pragmatic justification for at least reducing the consumption of meat. Rearing livestock produces methane, which is 23 times more powerful than carbon dioxide as an agent of global warming.
In a small way, Lord Stern dramatises the conundrum that hangs over the negotiations that have been taking place in Bangkok, before the Copenhagen summit in December. Methane is still produced by livestock reared for functions other than human consumption. In economies that are still heavily dependent on animals as both a source of goods for sale and a form of transport and in nations whose diets are mainly vegetarian in any case, Lord Stern’s demand for behavioural change will seem at the same time both irrelevant and presumptuous.
The extent to which developing nations — India, China, Russia and Brazil in particular — are willing to submit to environmental regulations that did not impede the growth of the richer countries has always been a sticking point of environmental progress. Much of the conversation has been about this grand bargain.
As well as committing to further reductions in their own greenhouse gas emissions, the industrialised nations have been hammering out the details of how they can help the poorer nations with their progress towards, for example, renewable energy and clean technology. The rich countries have also been trying to devise adaptive measures to mitigate the impact of climate change, including sea defences, fresh water supplies and new crop varieties. Mitigation, though, is fiendishly expensive. Reliable estimates suggest that $100 billion per year may be needed.
The developing world is looking to Copenhagen to deliver a deal that enshrines proportionate responsibility from nations at such different stages of development and, therefore, different levels of assumed guilt. In June the G8 and a number of large developing countries agreed that the average temperature rise since pre-industrial times should be limited to 2C. This is unachievable unless the targets set at Rio in 1992 and Kyoto in 1997 are made more ambitious.
The mood music, from Bangkok and from the agreement reached between India and China, means it is probable that a deal of sorts can be done. The negotiations over Copenhagen have also, in contrast to those before Kyoto, benefited from the enthusiastic engagement of the United States. It would be both ill advised and a poor advertisement for the way he has shifted his country’s policy if Barack Obama were not to attend the December summit.
Agreements about emissions reduction are just part of the solution. Finding ways to live both wisely and well is the great scientific quest of our age. But that does not make a comprehensive deal at Copenhagen unimportant. It may be that the 192 governments agree a framework, the tortuous details of which are thrashed out later. Not that there is much time left. The Kyoto Protocol runs out in 2012 and the deleterious impacts of climate change are already visible in some of the poorest plains of the Earth. As Auden wrote, time is short and history to the defeated may say alas, but cannot help nor pardon.
